Tuesday, August 04, 2009

Cash for Clunkers: I Don't Buy It

The cash for clunkers program has been wildly successful if you judge by the fact that the first billion dollars in the plan has run out in a matter of days. This money was expected to last well into the fall. The program has apparently done a lot to get people to buy new cars, and getting people to spend money is the whole point of a stimulus program, right? Well, I don't buy it.

Let me start by saying that the program is clearly doing some good. Yes, it did get folks to open their wallets, and clearly some ol' gas guzzlers are going to get scrapped, but is that enough? As far as I am concerned, this stimulus program was pretty much a give away to American car companies. Those very same companies to which the government has already given billions of our dollars.

If the goal of the plan was to get gas guzzling cars and trucks off the road, why did the program pay consumers $3,500 for a minute increase in gas mileage? Folks who traded-in an SUV or light truck could get away with an increase of only a couple of miles in gas mileage and still participate in the program. I can't prove this, but I am willing to bet that in many cases the CO2 emissions required to produce and deliver a new car greatly exceeded the energy that would be saved by the small MPG increase. If the reason for the program is environmental, why not require buyers to replace their vehicles with hybrid cars that would get at least 40 MPG? The answer is simple: such fuel efficient cars are made by foreign manufacturers, and we can't be giving money away to foreigners... even if those cars are produced by Japanese companies here in the US... nah, we can talk about the environment, but giving money to foreigners?! Unthinkable.

Second, how does destroying our assets improve our situation? Cars traded-in under the cash for clunkers program are destroyed. Yes, that's right, they are taken off the road and shredded. How does that help our national economy? Should we boost our construction industry by bulldozing old houses? Would we be better off as a nation if we destroyed our bridges so we could build new ones? We are taking assets that could be re-used and we are dumping them. How can that possibly make us richer as a nation? Is there some alchemy involved here?

Finally, this program is no doubt inflicting severe collateral damage on charities who would otherwise receive many of the vehicles being traded-in as donations. Here is some anecdotal evidence for that happening.

The only sound reasoning for such a program, in my opinion, is the environmental rationale, however those are clearly secondary and minor in the way the program is designed, as far as I can tell.

After I finished writing this post, I read this article which suggests that folks are buying cars with better fuel economy than is required by the Cash for Clunkers rules. If that is indeed the case, my objections on environmental reasons may be over stated (even though the combined gas mileage average is clearly far lower than it could be). We'll see.

Enjoyed this post? Please consider subscribing to Money and Such by free RSS Feed or by email. You can also follow me on Twitter.

Monday, August 03, 2009

Demand Health Care Reform!

A monumental battle is playing out in Washington, between those who strive for health care reform, and those who are doing everything in their power to maintain the staus-quo. The American people must stand-up and tell Congress that we do not only demand reform, but that we demand meaningful and sustainable reform that will guarantee health coverage to all Americans.

I call on my readers to take action to make sure that the first chance for real reform in over a decade is not wasted. We must make our voices heard.

Visit HealthReform to understand where we are, what we need to change and how we can get there. Join the fight!

Here is some data from that site which tells a very clear and well substantiated story for why health care reform is required for California. You can get similar information about the state where you live:
  • Roughly 19.7 million people in California get health insurance on the job1, where family premiums average $13,297, about the annual earning of a full-time minimum wage job. 2
  • Since 2000 alone, average family premiums have increased by 114 percent in California.3
  • Household budgets are strained by high costs: 19 percent of middle-income California families spend more than 10 percent of their income on health care.4
  • High costs block access to care: 13 percent of people in California report not visiting a doctor due to high costs.5
  • California businesses and families shoulder a hidden health tax of roughly $1,400 per year on premiums as a direct result of subsidizing the costs of the uninsured.6


AFFORDABLE HEALTH COVERAGE IS INCREASINGLY OUT OF REACH IN CALIFORNIA

  • 19 percent of people in California are uninsured, and 71 percent of them are in families with at least one full-time worker.7
  • The percent of Californians with employer coverage is declining: from 58 to 54 percent between 2000 and 2007.8
  • While small businesses make up 77 percent of California businesses,9 only 46 percent of them offered health coverage benefits in 2006.10
  • Choice of health insurance is limited in California. Kaiser Permanente alone constitutes 24 percent of the health insurance market share in California, with the top two insurance providers accounting for 44 percent.11
  • Choice is even more limited for people with pre-existing conditions. In California, premiums can vary based on demographic factors and health status, and coverage can exclude pre-existing conditions or even be denied completely in some cases.
To read the citations and end notes cited above, follow this link.

Enjoyed this post? Please consider subscribing to Money and Such by free RSS Feed or by email. You can also follow me on Twitter.

Friday, July 31, 2009

Map: It Really is a Global Recession...

Moody's has released this map showing the impact of the global recession. Click on each of the countries to get more interesting snippets of information.

It looks like almost the entire world is in the grip of this economic downturn. Who's still doing well? China, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt... all the good guys... well, to be quite honest there are also a few democracies that are doing OK: India and Panama, being the two that I can spot off-hand.

Enjoyed this post? Please consider subscribing to Money and Such by free RSS Feed or by email. You can also follow me on Twitter.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

Health Care: The Dirty War

The battle over the President's health care initiative is gaining momentum. I have previously aligned myself with the forces calling for a drastic reform of the US health care system, and if anything, I think that the bills currently making their way through Congress don't go nearly far enough. However, those who profit from the status quo are clearly mounting a counter-offensive in an effort to kill health care reform yet again.

Last week, a colleague sent me this link, purportedly an official Congressional chart showing the structure of the health care organization after the proposed reform. If you open the link you'll be shocked and amazed at what appears to be a byzantine maze of bureaucracy. Perfect. This is exactly what the powers behind this document want you to think. However if you look carefully, you will see that this is not an unbiased document, it is, in fact, a biased piece of propaganda, a weapon, if you will, in the dirty war for the future of health care in this country.

This document, while apparently stored on a legitimate Congressional server, was prepared by the Republican Staff of the Joint Economic Committee (see lower left hand corner of the document) and was submitted by Kevin Brady , Republican Congressman of Texas who, according to the Washington Post, has voted with his party 94.5% of the time in the current Congress.

Well, some of my colleagues took this document - which is intentionally designed to look confusing and intimidating - to be the actual proposal put before Congress. If the chart is so confusing, goes the rhetoric, how can the actual plan be any better?

Here is my take. I am not versed in the full details of the bills that are now circulating through Congress, but what I do know is that if you resort of misinformation or misdirection to drive your point home, something is truly wrong here. It may very well be that Congressman Brady has some productive points to contribute to the discussion. Hell, he may even have the holy grail of health care which he can deliver to Congress to the sound of grand applause by the American people. If so, let him be constructive. However, from reading the papers and watching the talk shows, it seems to me that Republicans are simply doing their utmost to scuttle the President's health care reform, regardless of the consequences to the American people. Forget about being constructive. Forget about finding a solution to a critical problem effecting all of our lives. All that seems to matter to them is the chance to deliver what they think will be a critical blow to the President's political standing.

I think enough is enough. Health care must be reformed. We all know it. Even those moneyed interests who stand to gain from maintaining the status quo (only they are cynically pushing for their short term financial interest, rather than for the long term betterment of society). If you have valid points to make, make them. Come to the table and argue for the type of change you would like to see, but enough with the scare tactics, misdirection and politics already. We need leadership, not idiocy.


Enjoyed this post? Please consider subscribing to Money and Such by free RSS Feed or by email. You can also follow me on Twitter.

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

The Inflation or Deflation Song... Literally...

I saw this first on the Finance Professor blog. Very funny. I am squarely in the inflation camp myself. I swear this guy sounds like Kermit the frog when sings. Not green though...






Enjoyed this post? Please consider subscribing to Money and Such by free RSS Feed or by email. You can also follow me on Twitter.